Conspiracy theories and debates surrounding the Oscars have sparked discussions at the high school, with some questioning the relevance of the annual awards show.
The Oscars, presented by the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, recognize excellence in film through voting by Academy members. However, the most recent ceremony on March 2, 2025, has led some to question the integrity and significance of the event.
Some South Hadley High School students and faculty have voiced skepticism about the awards.
“The Oscars are just an excuse for a bunch of people in Hollywood to try and gain fame,” said history department chair Timothy Balut. He added that while he doesn’t believe the entire show is rigged, he questions its importance. “I don’t think we need these award shows telling us what’s the best. The Oscars don’t matter anymore.”
Others believe the awards may have flaws, but they still serve a purpose.
Sophomore Jane Samlall, who has performed in multiple school musicals, emphasized that the industry should not be solely focused on awards. “I feel like [performers] might give up hope, but when being an actor, it’s important to realize that it’s not always about winning. It’s about putting your work out there and doing what you love,” she said.
One actor who puts out his work in hopes that people enjoy it rather than for fame and fortune is Timothée Chalamet.
Sophomore Kate Phillips, an annual Oscars viewer, suggested the event should reflect a wider range of opinions or be discontinued altogether. “Make it a reflection on people’s opinions or don’t hold them at all,” she said.
Upsets surrounded Cynthia Erivo’s failure to win an Oscar. Fans were hoping she would finally achieve EGOT status, which includes winning an Emmy, Grammy, Oscar, and Tony.
The 98th Academy Awards are scheduled for March 15, 2026. Until then, debates over the show’s relevance will likely continue, as viewers and industry professionals question whether the Oscars still hold value in today’s entertainment landscape.
